Advanced Placement Strategy: A Framework for Identifying School-Level Barriers to AP Success

In 2009, approximately 7,000 Tennessee students with the academic preparation necessary to pass Advanced Placement (AP) exams entered high school. Four years later, only half of those students had succeeded on an AP exam, and the rates were even lower for economically disadvantaged students. Why?

AP courses are one of several early postsecondary opportunities through which students can experience college-level curriculum and potentially earn college credits while still in high school. These types of opportunities include dual enrollment and dual credit courses, as well as the Advanced Placement (AP) and International Baccalaureate (IB) programs. By studying the AP pipeline in the state, we hope to identify the existing barriers and potential solutions that would expand student access to these types of rigorous courses.

When we first set out to understand the state of Advanced Placement in Tennessee, we knew that our high school students graduate having taken and passed fewer AP exams than their peers across the nation. What we didn’t know was why and how to begin thinking about solutions. The first step in the process was to identify the students who are likely to be successful on an AP exam. We found that high-achieving eighth-graders have a very high potential to earn a three or higher on an AP exam. Following this group of students, we then examined whether they had access to AP courses in their school, whether they enrolled in these courses, and whether they actually sat for the AP test.

We also looked at how these problems differed for economically disadvantaged students compared to their non-economically disadvantaged peers. At the state level we saw issues at every step along the pathway. Which led us to ask, do all schools struggle with all of these issues? Not surprisingly, the answer is “no.” Schools, like students, experience different problems that require differentiated interventions. The Office of Research and Policy’s latest research report, Advanced Placement Strategy: A Framework for Identifying School-Level Barriers to AP Success, details the issues schools encounter when moving academically prepared students along the AP pipeline, from access to success. Student-level data are used to highlight specific issues that schools face: (1) low preparation, (2) low access, (3) low enrollment, (4) differential enrollment, (5) low test-taking, and (6) differential test-taking.  The paper lays out a framework to identify where schools are experiencing difficulty moving students predicted to succeed on AP courses through the pipeline to AP success.

We know that these problems are solvable and are encouraged that many schools are succeeding at moving students through the pipeline at various points. But we still have work to do. The Tennessee Department of Education is committed to expanding early postsecondary opportunities for high school students. This is directly aligned with one of the priorities in SCORE’s 2013-14 State of Education in Tennessee report. As the report points out, “too few Tennesseans graduate high school prepared for success in college and career.”  The report also identifies that a priority for 2014 should be to “increase and expand opportunities for high school students to participate in rigorous coursework, including Advanced Placement, International Baccalaureate, dual credit, and dual enrollment courses.”  It is important to ensure that students have access to a diverse portfolio of early postsecondary opportunities, so they can enroll in rigorous courses that best meet their educational needs.

You can read more details in the Office of Research and Policy’s research report, Advanced Placement Strategy: A Framework for Identifying School-Level Barriers to AP Success: http://tn.gov/education/data/doc/AP_report.pdf

This blog post was written by Emily Carter and Mary Batiwalla.

Mary Batiwalla is a Policy Analyst in the Office of Research and Policy at the Tennessee Department of Education. She has been a high school Spanish teacher in schools in Arkansas and Georgia.  Prior to her current role, Mary assisted in education research at the National Center on Scaling Up Effective Schools, SCORE, and a project funded by the National Science Foundation studying the effectiveness of mentoring for beginning middle school math teachers. She completed a Master of Public Policy at Peabody College of Education, Vanderbilt University.

Data Tell Fuller Story of Tennessee’s NAEP Performance

Tennessee set an ambitious goal in 2009 for our education system to be the fastest-improving among all states. The results are in: Tennessee students in fourth and eighth grade surpassed their peers across the country in overall gains on national math and reading tests, making Tennessee the fastest-improving state in the nation. Not only did Tennessee have the greatest improvement this year, but the gains are the most that any state has ever made since NAEP began testing all states 10 years ago. There were gains by subject and grade level for the test scale SCOREs, as well as the percent of students scoring proficient or above. Continue reading

Redefining the School District in Tennessee

Over the past few years, Tennessee has taken important steps to improve public education. With a focus on higher standards, great teaching, turning around low performing schools, and using data in new and important ways, Tennessee has made significant progress. Even with student achievement improving, there is still a lot of work left to do before every student graduates high school prepared for college and the workforce. Continue reading

The road to teaching

I have met some amazing teachers in Tennessee. Whether serving elementary or high school students in rural or urban areas across the state, they are all dedicated to their profession and most importantly to the success of their students. We spend a lot of time thinking and talking about what we want from teachers, but we do not necessarily give enough attention to the preparation and ongoing training that they go through to become great teachers. In the process of gathering information for SCORE’s latest policy memo, Teacher Licensure in Tennessee, I found myself immersed in the world of teacher training and requirements. The topic of licensure looks at everything from the programs that prepare teachers to the regulations that determine the subject areas and grade levels they can teach. Continue reading

The Smoky Mountains – Welcome to Class

One of the most memorable experiences from high school was the summer that I spent building trails in Denali National Park, Alaska. Not only was the work itself challenging and rewarding, but it also gave me a unique opportunity to learn about local ecology and culture outside of a traditional classroom setting. I didn’t realize at the time that I was engaging in hands-on, experiential learning and an integrated curriculum, but I loved every minute of it. Continue reading

Saving Superman

A recent report by TNTP brings to light a very real crisis that has been holding back student learning across the country – we are failing to keep the best teachers where they are needed most. Teachers guide and educate our students every day. To many, the best teachers are like super heroes. Continue reading

Listening to Educators

As part of an effort to learn more about the implementation of Tennessee’s First to the Top plan to improve student achievement, my colleague Laura Moore and I have been talking with educators across the state and gaining an incredibly valuable perspective on what is changing in classrooms, schools, and school districts. While policymakers can speak to the overall structure of the reform initiatives, it is important to hear from the practitioners responsible for carrying out this significant work in the field. As Sir Michael Barber said, “Winning Race to the Top is at best only 10 percent of transforming a state’s education system; the remaining 90 percent is implementation, implementation, implementation.” I wanted to know more about what that 90 percent really looks like. Continue reading